web analytics
Ga naar de inhoud
Choosing an SEO agency

Can an SEO agency guarantee first place on Google?

No. Google says so itself: no one can guarantee a number one ranking on Google. Google decides the order and changes it constantly, and on the map your position also depends on where the person searching is at that moment. An agency that offers a guarantee anyway is promising something outside its control. What a good agency can promise: clear work, honest reporting and an approach that follows Google’s rules.

By Eric Walker · Last updated: October 2026

What Google says

On its page for businesses hiring an SEO, Google is very direct. No one can guarantee a number one ranking on Google. It also warns about companies that do promise it, and about anyone claiming a special relationship with Google or the ability to submit your site with priority. That does not exist.

On the map it is even less possible

For local searches, distance plays a big role. Google names it as one of three things that decide your position, alongside relevance and prominence. Someone searching “plumber” in Schaesberg sees a different order than someone in Hoensbroek.

You can be at the top on one street and fifth three kilometres away. In local SEO there is no single “first place”. That is why I measure positions at several points across a town, not from one address.

How guarantees usually work

Agencies that guarantee something anyway usually do it in one of these ways:

  • Search terms nobody uses. Ranking first for “cheap emergency roofer Ubachsberg” is easy, but brings nothing.
  • Money back, with conditions. Read the small print: the term is often long and the conditions loose enough that the agency is always right.
  • Pay per position. You pay for every search term in the top 10, including ones that do not matter.
  • Ads as results. A top spot through Google Ads is bought, and disappears when you stop paying.

Called with a guarantee?

Many business owners get calls from companies saying they can put you “at the top of Google”, sometimes even “on behalf of Google”. Be careful. A Google Business Profile is free, and you cannot buy a place in the regular results or on the map from Google. If the caller speaks Dutch fast and you only half follow, all the more reason to ask for everything in writing.

What a good agency does promise

  • What it will do each month, concretely.
  • A baseline at the start, so you can later see what changed.
  • Reporting on things that matter, such as calls and enquiries.
  • Working within Google’s guidelines, so your profile is not put at risk.
  • That your profile and website always stay in your name.

How I handle it

I do not promise a position. With monthly support, I show you where you stand in the towns that matter to you, what I did and what comes next. If something is not working, I say so. For realistic timing, see how long local SEO takes.

Sources

Related questions

Prefer honest expectations?

Send me your business name and town. I will tell you what is realistic, even if it sounds less exciting than a guarantee.