Usually not. An honest negative review about someone’s experience is protected as free expression, even when it is harsh. It is different when someone accuses you of specific things that are untrue, or insults you badly. That can amount to defamation or insult, which are criminal offences under Dutch law. In practice, though, the solution more often goes through Google or the civil courts than through the police.
A customer who writes that they waited too long, that the bill was higher than expected, or that they are unhappy with the result is giving an opinion. That is allowed, even if you disagree and even if the tone is sharp.
When Dutch judges look at reviews, they ask whether the criticism has a basis in what actually happened. A review only becomes a problem when it clearly crosses a line.
The Dutch Criminal Code (Wetboek van Strafrecht) has a few articles that can apply:
“The service was poor” is an opinion. “This man stole money from me” is an accusation of a specific fact. If that is not true, it comes close to smaad or laster. For a sole trader, such a review often affects you personally as well, and that matters.
Besides criminal law there is civil law. A review can be unlawful (onrechtmatig) if it harms you without good reason, for instance because it is fake, factually wrong or needlessly hurtful. The court then weighs freedom of expression against your interest in a good name.
Through that route a court can order a review to be removed, a correction to be published, or damages to be paid. In 2019, the Amsterdam District Court used it to order Google to remove fake reviews and hand over the details of the accounts behind them.
This is not legal advice, and Dutch law differs from US or UK defamation law in important ways. Whether a review is unlawful or criminal in your case depends on the exact wording and circumstances. Speak to a Dutch lawyer before taking action.
More on reporting in whether you can get a bad Google review removed.
Do not threaten a lawyer or the police in your public reply. Other readers mostly see a business that cannot take criticism, and the fuss only makes the review more visible. Never share the customer’s name, address or other details they did not share themselves, either. That creates a problem for you instead.
A calm reply and a report to Google solve most cases. See how to respond to a bad Google review.
I cannot give legal advice, but I can help you judge whether a report to Google stands a chance and how to reply without making things worse.
Also from Eric: ReAlign Marketing in Denver
This site would like to use Google Analytics to count visitors. That places cookies, and only happens if you agree. Privacy statement