Usually for one of four reasons: they are closer to the person searching, their primary category fits the search better, they have more and more recent reviews, or their profile and website are more complete. Sometimes Google simply trusts your profile less, for example because your address is written differently in different places. You can usually work out which it is in about half an hour.
Google shows everyone different results depending on where they are. Search from your own workshop and you will often see yourself at the top, because you are literally the closest business. A customer three kilometres away sees something completely different.
So search from where your customers are, or ask someone in that neighbourhood to search and send you a screenshot. To get a precise picture, measure your position on a grid of points around your business. That is how rank tracking works when I do it.
Distance is one of the three things Google itself names in how local ranking works. You cannot change it. What you can do is make relevance and prominence strong enough that you still show up further from your address.
If someone searches for roofer and your primary category is General contractor while theirs is Roofing contractor, they start ahead. You can see a competitor’s category in Google Maps, right under their business name.
The number counts, but so does how recent they are. In BrightLocal’s 2026 survey of 1,002 US adults, 74 percent said they look for reviews from the last three months. A competitor with forty reviews, the latest from last week, looks more active to customers than one with sixty reviews where the newest is a year old.
More services filled in, more photos of real work, accurate opening hours and a website with a page for exactly that service. Each of those helps Google connect their profile to the search.
Put their profile next to yours and go through this list:
After ten minutes you usually see where the gap is. It is rarely one big reason. More often it is a few small ones that add up.
If your profile and website are only in English, that alone can put you behind. Your customers search in Dutch, so a Dutch-speaking competitor whose services read loodgieter and lekkage reparatie matches those searches more closely. You do not need to speak Dutch to fix that. The service names and website text just need to be in the language your customers use.
Some competitors add keywords to their business name, list an address where they do not operate, or buy reviews. That goes against Google’s guidelines. In Google Maps you can use Suggest an edit to report a wrong name or an address that does not exist.
Only do this when you are sure. Reporting a real business because it is in your way achieves nothing, and teaches Google that your reports cannot be trusted. Most of the time, working on your own profile pays off more.
Also from Eric: ReAlign Marketing in Denver
This site would like to use Google Analytics to count visitors. That places cookies, and only happens if you agree. Privacy statement